'

MSI's M.2 Shield has been found to raise SSD temperatures

MSI's M.2 Shield has been found to raise SSD temperatures

MSI's M.2 Shield has been found to raise SSD temperatures

MSI's M.2 Shield has been found to raise SSD temperatures

 
In some recent thermal testing that was conducted by GamersNexus, the website found that MSI's M.2 Shield has actually had a negative effect on an M.2 SSD's thermal performance, raise SSD temperatures instead of lowering them like advertised.  
 
Below is GamerNexus' video on MSI's "Heat Shield", which showcases several design flaws on the product, which uses an exceptionally thin metallic shield as a heatsink which does little to help cool the SSD (adds little to no additional surface area to cool the SSD) and has the unwanted side effect of actually trapping heat under the SSD, increasing the temperature of the underside of M.2 SSDs. 
 
In GamerNexus' testing, it was found that the top side of the SSD had thermals lower by 1-2 degrees celsius at idle and under load, with the bottom of the SSD having thermals increase by around 4 degrees at both in idle scenarios and under load. 
 
 

  

This raises a major issue with modern M.2 SSDs, which have components on both sides of the PCB, causing heat to be produced at both the top and bottom of the SSD. This makes these SSDs difficult to cool effectively, especially when under heavy loads. 

While some M.2 SSDs have been found to suffer for thermal throttling under load, it must also be said that this only happens under benchmarking loads, as no day-to-day applications can produce enough data to cause such thermal loads. GamerNexus' tests were conducted over a 60 minute period under IOMeter, which is an SSD load that is higher than any consumer system could produce outside of benchmarks.  

Modern M.2 SSDs can offer speeds in the realms of several GB per second, which is not a load that any system can deliver in a real-world scenario for 60 minutes. This would require multiple terabytes of data to be written to the SSD, which is not only larger than the capacity of all M.2 SSD but far in excess of anything that could be defined as a consumer workload. 

 

MSI's M.2 Shield has been found to raise SSD temperatures

 

 

While MSI's M.2 Shield has been found to increase thermal loads under benchmarking loads, the question needs to be asked if this is if this will actually affect consumers. Will anyone actually have their SSDs under full write loads for 60-minutes at any given time? 

 

You can join the discussion on MSI's M.2 Shield raising SSD temperatures on the OC3D Forums

 

«Prev 1 2 Next»

Most Recent Comments

27-01-2017, 14:43:41

Thelosouvlakia
it was a "brilliant" idea made by people who have no idea of thermodynamics whatsoever every material has a maximum thermal limit it reaches a point where it would absorb heat but then it will reach equilibrium after that point the temperature is going to be identical if not lower than the item it is in contact with...Quote

27-01-2017, 15:41:06

AngryGoldfish
I read the article today by Gamers Nexus. What a shame its pants because it looks cool. I guess the marketing worked.Quote

27-01-2017, 15:41:41

green_arrow
Well a possible solution is to remove the heatsink.
Although I think someone will come up with a solution "off the shield".Quote

27-01-2017, 15:44:05

Chrazey
Doesn't ASUS offer something similar on their new Z270I Strix mITX motherboard?...Quote

27-01-2017, 19:00:11

NeverBackDown
You need active cooling in order for the heatsink to work. Otherwise after a certain period of time, it'll actually start to cook it. Heatsinks don't magically cool themselves.. GG MSI.Quote
Reply
x

Register for the OC3D Newsletter

Subscribing to the OC3D newsletter will keep you up-to-date on the latest technology reviews, competitions and goings-on at Overclock3D. We won't share your email address with ANYONE, and we will only email you with updates on site news, reviews, and competitions and you can unsubscribe easily at any time.

Simply enter your name and email address into the box below and be sure to click on the links in the confirmation emails that will arrive in your e-mail shortly after to complete the registration.

If you run into any problems, just drop us a message on the forums.